THIS BLOG IS MY BLOG. THIS BLOG IS MY BLOG. Welcome to the Home of Hyperopia.: Why Do We Have Taxes? - GOOD QUESTION!!

Tuesday, January 05, 2010

Why Do We Have Taxes? - GOOD QUESTION!!

A good friend recommended this article (called "Why Do We Have Taxes?) in the context of a discussion we were having on Facebook about health care and rights and whether the services a government requires its constitutents to perform constitutes slavery. I had recommended this article (called "What Is A Right?") to him, prompting his recommendation.

I thought the "Why Do We Have Taxes?" article deserved a line by line refutation.

At least its second paragraph certainly does.

Because so much of what its author says in those paragraphs is incorrect or untrue.

  • Only without governments would there be no taxes; therefore, without taxes there would be no governments.
This "therefore" item is simply not true, not logical. Governments have a variety of ways to get money, and taxation is only one of them. There are also tariffs. There are also bonds. Note that the U.S. didn't have any income tax until 1916 (or thereabouts). Note also that the federal government had no (or a massively limited) ability to tax under the Articles of Confederation (which was great), and nevertheless, the federal government existed.
  • Taxation is one of the several ways by which governments raise money to pay for the goods and services that they are called on to provide.
This sentence is true except for the part that says "they are called on to provide." Governments aren't called on to provide the services they fund through taxation. Governments grant to themselves monopoly privileges to be the only source from whom their constituents (consumers) are allowed to obtain their services. For example, the U.S. Postal Service. It's against the law (a law made by the government, not the people who wanted the service) for certain kinds of mail to be delivered from one place to another. For another example, taxi cabs. It's generally against the law (a law made by the government, not the people who wanted the service) for people who don't have the proper government-issued credentials (e.g., medallions, etc.) to accept money from a person to drive that person from one place to another, even if the passenger wants to be taken.

In the case of the USPS, the laws were passed because private entrepreneurs were outperforming the government mail service on price and quality of service. Government hates competition.

In the case of taxi cabs, there are many stories about how government policies artificially limiting the number of licensed cabbies in various cities have made life worse for people who don't have cars and need transportation so that the cab companies and cab drivers who do have the licenses can charge prices in excess of what they could charge if the government wasn't limiting - by force of law - entry to the field.
  • Governments lack the major sources of revenue available to other sectors of the economy and must therefore rely on taxes to finance the majority of their expenditures.
This is not true. Governments provide stuff. Governments could charge money for the stuff, except that, because they don't have a profit/loss feedback mechanism, governments can't provide the stuff as efficiently, effectively, or economically as enterprises that do have to generate profits to survive. So governments get out-competed. (Naturally.) So governments do rely on taxes (and other compulsory means) to get money to do what they do. But it's not because the institution is called "government" that it needs to extract wealth by force to operate. It's because of the nature of the institution (operating outside the constraints of the profit and loss feedback mechanism guarantees inefficient, ineffective, and uneconomic operations).
  • Unlike businesses, governments generally produce very few goods and services that can be sold, especially at a profit.
Not true. People pay money to drive on roads. People pay money to have police services provided. People pay money to walk around in nature. People pay money to be educated. People pay money to have records maintained of their transactions. People pay money to communicate with one another.

In fact, completely contrary to what this author says, I bet that for every single good or service a government provides, there is a transaction involving the exact same good or service being purchased in a private transaction.
  • In addition, governments don’t have wage and investment income as do individuals and families.
This may be true, at least as to the wage income. As to the investment income, I'm sure as a factual matter that it isn't true. I'm sure governments do invest some of the money it extracts through force from its constituents in transactions that pay a return (i.e., governments loan money at interest).

Governments do not generate enough profits from their investments to pay for all the activities they undertake. Instead they force their constituents to finance the difference.
  • Without these sources of income, governments have little choice but to finance their spending needs by assessing businesses as well as individuals.
Here the author has, I think, lost the thread of his "argument" a little bit. I'm not even sure what this sentence is saying. The previous sentences speak to governments needing funding for their activities and indicate that, in fact, governments do obtain funding from individuals and families (which is true). But this sentence seems to be saying governments DON'T tax businesses as well (not true).

Moving on ...

  • Governments are continually searching for additional funds to pay for the needs of their citizens, businesses, and bureaucrats.
This is actually true. Governments are relentless in their pursuit of previously un-plundered populations. Understood in this (accurate) way, this sentence is much more ominous than the author probably intended it.
  • At the local level, taxes support spending for schools roads, libraries, athletic facilities, fire and police services, and the salaries of county and municipal employees.
This is true, but as noted above, each of these goods and services are not only being simultaneously provided by private businesses to private individuals in private transactions, each of these goods and services CAN be provided to private folks by private folks. (Government has appropriated for itself the position of primary provider of these goods and services. And it uses force to keep competition from taking that position away from it. (Except at the margins -- see, e.g., FEDEX, private security firms, and home schooling.)
  • States collect taxes for highway construction and upkeep, public colleges, buildings, and law enforcement.
More of the same.
  • The federal government levies taxes in order to provide its citizens with an interstate highway system, a capable military force, health services, an Internal Revenue Service, thousands of parks and monuments, and scores of other things.
More of the same.

SKIPPING TO THE END (of the article) ...

  • In summation, although unpopular (and many may argue, unfair), taxes are a necessity.
Not true.
  • The standard of living of a modern society demands it; governments must collect the revenues in order to provide the goods and services that their citizens need, want and demand.
Not true. Nobody needs government to provide the goods and services it provides. Plenty of people don't want the government to provide those goods and services. And if there is demanding to be done, it ought be to be that government get out of the business of trying to provide goods and services and let the profit-seeking, loss-averse private businesses who don't have the luxury of funding their activities through coercive wealth extraction improve the world for us all.

Photo Credit:


Anonymous Anonymous said...

speed dating and singles partys in london [url=]atlanta singles travel[/url] meet singles john cusack dating

10:41 AM, February 26, 2010  
Anonymous Anonymous said...

Do You interesting of [b]Viagra 100mg dosage[/b]? You can find below...
[size=10]>>>[url=][b]Viagra 100mg dosage[/b][/url]<<<[/size]

[b]Bonus Policy[/b]
Order 3 or more products and get free Regular Airmail shipping!
Free Regular Airmail shipping for orders starting with $200.00!

Free insurance (guaranteed reshipment if delivery failed) for orders starting with $300.00!

Generic Viagra (sildenafil citrate; brand names include: Aphrodil / Edegra / Erasmo / Penegra / Revatio / Supra / Zwagra) is an effective treatment for erectile dysfunction regardless of the cause or duration of the problem or the age of the patient.
Sildenafil Citrate is the active ingredient used to treat erectile dysfunction (impotence) in men. It can help men who have erectile dysfunction get and sustain an erection when they are sexually excited.
Generic Viagra is manufactured in accordance with World Health Organization standards and guidelines (WHO-GMP). Also you can find on our sites.
Generic Viagra is made with thorough reverse engineering for the sildenafil citrate molecule - a totally different process of making sildenafil and its reaction. That is why it takes effect in 15 minutes compared to other drugs which take 30-40 minutes to take effect.
Even in the most sexually liberated and self-satisfied of nations, many people still yearn to burn more, to feel ready for bedding no matter what the clock says and to desire their partner of 23 years as much as they did when their love was brand new.
The market is saturated with books on how to revive a flagging libido or spice up monotonous sex, and sex therapists say “lack of desire” is one of the most common complaints they hear from patients, particularly women.

2:38 AM, March 18, 2010  
Anonymous Anonymous said...
[url=]beating drug urine screenings[/url] hallucinogenic drugs wikipedia [url=]omnicef used for[/url]
popular drug for long term care patienst
[url=]hospitals required to report drug overdoses[/url] law digital scale drug paraphernalia [url=]zovirax oral ointment[/url]
ways to change the feild of pharmacy
[url=]generic cialis softtabs[/url] nonsteroidal anti inflammatory drugs [url=]zyprexa lawsuit[/url] what do people on drugs look like [url=]clonidine tekturna propranolol[/url]

3:41 AM, March 30, 2010  
Anonymous Anonymous said...

penis size effects of aging [url=]altace[/url] michelle obama said his medical nerve disorder treat treatment ancient medical history
alternative medicine cancer [url=]blood pressure[/url] dakota medical foundation [url=]american pain medicine inc[/url]

3:32 AM, April 01, 2010  
Anonymous Anonymous said...

gt courtage automobile details new iberia louisiana dodge dealer
[url=]mercedes benz e320 oil pressure[/url] evelution of the automobile [url=]honda recon transmisom[/url]
mercedes benz s 430 fuse block
[url=]modified mercedes[/url] performance parts for dodge ram cummins [url=]comparatif hyundai tft[/url]
peoria auto used cars
[url=]colorado state automobile title[/url] auto speakers poping [url=]volvo certified automobiles glendale ca[/url]

12:27 AM, April 22, 2010  
Anonymous Anonymous said...

tenn travel oregan travel guide
[url=]arctic cat prowler long travel suspension[/url] tea travel kit [url=]cruise ship infinity[/url]
dover travel
[url=]valentine day travel deals[/url] travel bike [url=]boeing stearman pt 17 kaydet[/url]
kayack travel joes travel plaza [url=]expedia corporate travel travelers[/url]

7:27 PM, April 23, 2010  
Anonymous Anonymous said...

nutini new shoes different types of horseshoes [url=]used ski clothes[/url] victorian era fashion kleinfelder [url=]babes talk off their clothes[/url]

8:23 PM, April 30, 2010  
Anonymous Anonymous said...

mirrors designer bath porn rss chanels [url=]newborn boys hip hop clothes[/url] red shoes for nancy ralph lauren and magazine adds [url=]brenada strite rite munchkin shoes[/url]

10:42 PM, April 30, 2010  
Anonymous Anonymous said...

gently used clothes shops massachusetts interior designers mondrian [url=]designer radiators[/url] chanel hanbags new york lerner clothes [url=]opinions on merrill shoes[/url]

3:32 AM, May 03, 2010  
Anonymous Anonymous said...

heartbreaker dildo
[url=]mature asian anal[/url] adult wholesalers [url=]roped tit[/url]
girl and big blue dildo
[url=]kirsten price adult film[/url] free movies of xxx porn sexy [url=]free toon vids[/url]
sexy asses pics
[url=]sheath dildo panty[/url] pokemon ign sexy haruka pics [url=]sweet teen sex free movie[/url]
soccer moms anal sex
[url=]new england patriots adult pajamas[/url] xxx porn ffree [url=]juicy teen ass[/url]

12:18 AM, May 15, 2010  
Anonymous Anonymous said...

anal dildo lesbians
[url=]hentai bratz[/url] captive guys adult sites [url=]amateur mature vidoes[/url]
wife forced the dildo in my ass
[url=]xx adult movie[/url] adult entertainment brevard county florida [url=]gay businessmen[/url]
porn movies long free
[url=]free adult directory free porn[/url] online free hentai manga [url=]sologirl sweet asya lesbian kissing on bed[/url]
free porn hantai
[url=]how much does the adult feamle brain weigh[/url] lauren graham sexy scene from bad santa [url=]mature bukake[/url]

7:47 AM, May 15, 2010  
Anonymous Anonymous said...

sexy women with no bras
[url=]asaians porn[/url] adult western writers [url=]her erotic boudoir photo session[/url]
abduction adult game
[url=]donkey show video links adult[/url] gay adult exchange sydney [url=]toon boom cartoons movies[/url]
adult finder dallas singles
[url=]dermatological disorders adult dermatome[/url] direct contact food grade chain lubricant [url=]anal orgasm for men[/url]
free movies young teen porn
[url=]adult puzzles 1000 pieces rock n roll[/url] mateur xxx [url=]hariy bbw[/url]

2:14 PM, May 17, 2010  
Anonymous Anonymous said...

free movies free interracial fucking movie [url=]Matrimonio Compulsivo[/url] worst movie posters [url=]Werewolf[/url]
lesbian movie stars [url=]La Suerte De Emma[/url] boudicca the movie [url=]Surfs Up[/url]
movie plus 5 video tuner does not work with ati card [url=]Roary The Racing Car Roary Takes Off[/url] free movie download torrent [url=]Good Luck ChuckOOD LUCK CHUCK 16X9 UNRATED[/url]
horror movie mp3 [url=]Alex Jones - Matrix Of Evil[/url] jade marcela nyomi marcela lesbian movie [url=]Beowulf[/url]

7:26 AM, May 21, 2010  
Anonymous Anonymous said...

asda fashions getting adhesive off washed clothes [url=]camerons clothes the holiday[/url] erections under clothes clothes worn in spain [url=]store in maryland called valu city fashion[/url]

12:32 PM, May 29, 2010  
Anonymous Anonymous said...

facweb mineral [url=]lipitor[/url] home health business home based travel business legitimate
gum base denfri [url=]lopid[/url] tx gulf coast medical [url= ]allegra airline [/url] virginia emergency medical services
drug study of vitamin k in newborn [url=]No prescription online pharmacy[/url] performance medical devices
is it possible to not contract herpes without protection [url=]hyzaar[/url] online consultation medical prescription [url= ]world news involving drugs [/url] moose heart

9:21 AM, June 01, 2010  
Anonymous Anonymous said...

men in womens clothes men in womens clothes [url=]lauren christine monsig[/url] news family business includes issues fashion home washington joan melissa formal shoes [url=]ethnic clothes[/url]

4:30 PM, June 02, 2010  
Anonymous Anonymous said...

casino room deals in biloxi ms betting software totalizator bellys
[url=]south dakoda lottery[/url] sweetwater casino restruant [url=]on line play roulette game[/url]
online gambling banned
[url=]sports betting champ guide[/url] canadian lottery scam [url=]keno brother show[/url]
casino design estimation tools free printable bingo cards [url=]blackjack hotmail[/url]

5:47 AM, June 09, 2010  
Anonymous Anonymous said...

casinos in china free bonus baccarat internet casino game
[url=]bette midler jackpot[/url] lottery capital punishment [url=]minnesota state lottery[/url]
malta lottery result
[url=]calculate lottery odds[/url] case of paper bingo cards [url=]drifter slot download[/url]
windsor uk betting parlour crist seminole casinos [url=]blackjack odds online casino[/url]

10:34 AM, June 11, 2010  
Anonymous Anonymous said...

artic tale movie [url=]clockstoppers[/url] the red ballon and movie catherine bell movie scenes
movie look both ways [url=]the omega code[/url] underworld movie soundtrack seitgeist movie
thong babe movie [url=]smother[/url] uglies movie filming date
bunnicula the movie [url=]the great white hope[/url] antartica movie hbo movie line up
movie splicer for mac [url=]being erica[/url] horror movie listing gay free movie galleries

4:14 PM, July 05, 2010  
Anonymous Anonymous said...

Very shorts, simple and easy to understand, bet some more comments from your side would be great

8:38 PM, July 05, 2010  
Anonymous Anonymous said...

lord of the flies black and white movie [url=]don t come knocking[/url] office sex movie dane cook movie
free movie jenna jameson pornstar [url=]hackers[/url] blaze of glory movie download movie dvd
movie monster porn [url=]shark tank[/url] mike jitlov internet movie data base
kelly heros movie soundtrack [url=]the telling[/url] bala cynwyd movie dennis theather movie
free huge dildo movie [url=]my dinner with andre[/url] new movie downloads harry potter movie showings

2:18 AM, July 13, 2010  
Anonymous Farm Dog said...

i thought the fifth anonymous comment was the best

2:39 PM, January 06, 2011  

Post a Comment

<< Home