THIS BLOG IS MY BLOG. THIS BLOG IS MY BLOG. Welcome to the Home of Hyperopia.: On the Separation of Powers - Part 2

Friday, October 28, 2005

On the Separation of Powers - Part 2



Ron Paul has filed yet another important report highlighting the manifest misunderstandings attending the role of the federal judiciary in America.

***********

These sentences explain the reasons the judicial nomination process occasionally devolves into an outlandish spectacle include:
  • Federal courts ... have become unelected, unaccountable purveyors of social policy for the entire nation. Bitter partisan fights over Supreme Court nominees are inevitable simply because so much is at stake.

That is simply the truth. Of course that doesn't answer the question why? As in, why have the federal courts become purveyors of social policy for the nation? Somebody else has written about this reaching a similar conclusion, although I don't remember who and I can't find where, but I think there are two primary reasons this is the case.

The first reason goes back to Marbury v. Madison (at least I think that is true; remember, you are reading an analysis of the structure and history of the government of the United States as written by a person who earned a C- in Constitutional Law in law school). You see what happened was:

The people who put our government together generally had an agreement that there would be checks and balances whereby: (1) the extent to which the group that spends far too much time writing laws could screw things up for the general populace would be limited by (2) The Big Dog at the top of the heap who can decide whether to reject laws presented and (3) the group that was supposed to compare the substance and breadth of the laws enacted by the busy-bodies and the implementation and enforcement of those laws by The Big Dog to the limitations imposed by the founding (constating?) documents of the country.

But Supreme Court Chief Justice Marshall understood that out of that scrum whoever got to go "last" would have something of a dominating position. Recall the aphorism: he who laughs last laughs loudest. So in Marbury, he authored an opinion basically seizing the last laugh for the judicial branch. And in some bunch of other opinions that I can't identify (C-, remember), the federal courts decided to ignore the Tenth Amendment to the Constitution to the degree that many issues of local or state concern have been federalized during recent (and not so recent) decades.

(As an interesting (from this author's perspective, anyway) sidenote to this discussion, here is what current Chief Justice Roberts said during his confirmation hearings in response to a question about whether he thought Congress could, constitutionally, limit the jurisdiction of the federal courts by specific legislation (the relevant portion of the transcript is here):

"Well, I don't think -- on the question of
legislative attempts, I think my view is
the same now as it was 24 years ago, which
is that these are -- it's a bad idea. It's bad policy.

I was talking about the other question about
whether it's constitutional or not. And on that,
of course, I don't think I should express a
determinative view because, as you know,
these proposals do come up and one may be enacted.")

But I digress ...

The point of all this is that, rightly or wrongly, the federal judiciary is political. In no small part because the federal courts generally get the last say. So, one way to look at this is ... when a group of folks interested in living a particular way or having a particular rule be the law of the land lose their fight in one of what have now become the lesser venues (federal or state legislatures, federal or state regulatory agencies, state courts) , they take their fight to the federal judiciary. Accordingly, these groups of folks have a keen interest in the identity and ideology of the people who will be there to listen to them, to "hear their case" as it were.

P.S.
This post was written before Harriet Miers withdrew her name from consideration for a Supreme Court position. That is an interesting topic in its own right. I'm annoyed at people asserting Ms. Miers wasn't qualified. Just because she wasn't a judge before. As Ron Paul noted in the article linked above, that's ridiculous.

33 Comments:

Anonymous Anonymous said...

Words, words words.

8:33 AM, October 28, 2005  
Anonymous Anonymous said...

To Bill Brasky

9:52 AM, October 28, 2005  
Blogger FLAMINGO1 said...

Constitutional law is intriguing. Really, it is!

I long for the days when the members of congress were part time and the rest of the year they worked their farms/businesses.

State's Rights are dead. I realized that when our latest Supreme Court Chief Justice made the argument that states do not have the right to establish their own assisted suicide laws. How will they boot strap thatt one into being federal jurisdiction, I wonder. Might they use the commerce clause to argue that by dieing, I stop purchasing stuff in the stream of interstate commerce and thus they have the right to regulate that?

In any event, the Republican party used to be the small government/state's rights party. But I guess that philosophical position is dispensible if by adopting a counter position you can advance your party's real agenda which appears to be the abortion/right to life platform.

I'm out. I am officially a Libertarian as of this moment.

Bill Brasky was a mean drunk.

10:47 AM, October 28, 2005  
Anonymous States Rights Gist said...

the word 'that' is spelled with two t's. One at the beginning, and one at the end. NOT two t's at the end.

I guess you have some more apologizing and crying to do.

There is a tear in my beer.

Long live the Confederacy

10:52 AM, October 28, 2005  
Anonymous Cosby said...

Flizzle fluzzle wuzzle.

Jello Pudding Pops.

11:02 AM, October 28, 2005  
Blogger Dongley Shlongford said...

Poop spelled backwards is: Poop.

11:40 AM, October 28, 2005  
Anonymous Anonymous said...

Speaking of beer...has anyone tried Shiner 96??

11:41 AM, October 28, 2005  
Blogger FLAMINGO1 said...

I will never apologize to you states rights gist. It is my God given wright as an American too speell badly and right like an unedukated wall-mart shopper.

Your name should be State's Rights Gist, Mr. Gist. Remember, "State's" is possessive. The rights belong to the state...or at least they used to.

12:15 PM, October 28, 2005  
Blogger Dongley Shlongford said...

I require a fluffer to get into constitutional law as well....

12:49 PM, October 28, 2005  
Anonymous Anonymous said...

Schlitz 85.
Try it, you'll like it.

1:18 PM, October 28, 2005  
Anonymous State's Rights Gist said...

Yes FLMNG 1, you are correct.
I have been dead for almost 155 years, so I have lost some of my typing skills.

1:27 PM, October 28, 2005  
Anonymous Anonymous said...

Where are all the white women at?

2:16 PM, October 28, 2005  
Anonymous Anonymous said...

This blog is a Nazi dictatorship, censored by a duck loving, hurrican dodging never was.

2:18 PM, October 28, 2005  
Anonymous Anonymous said...

THIS POST HAS BEEN DELETED BY THE BLOG ADMINISTRATOR.

2:20 PM, October 28, 2005  
Blogger Dongley Shlongford said...

Sounds like you need to enjoy the calming properties of Polynesian Cartography.

2:24 PM, October 28, 2005  
Blogger FLAMINGO1 said...

Garrett may be a duck loving, hurricane dodging, never-was, however he is a loveable Nazi...sort of like the Nazis in Hogan's Heros. Just too zany and loveable to be involved in genocide.

3:32 PM, October 28, 2005  
Anonymous garrett said...

he also likey the poopy

3:58 PM, October 28, 2005  
Blogger FLAMINGO1 said...

There you go again, Bizzarro Garrett. You have such a fantastic ability to turn a fecal phrase!! Bravo!

5:16 PM, October 28, 2005  
Blogger Chris said...

Is Ron Paul your congressman?

9:29 AM, October 30, 2005  
Blogger garrett said...

Chris - in the most accurate sense of the words, Ron Paul is America's congressman. He is the only Representative I know who truly advocates for the broader interests of all Americans.

But no, to my regret, I do not live in Ron Paul's district. Ron Paul's district is along the Texas gulf coast. It's close to here, but we don't live in it.

Tom DeLay is the Congressman for where I live.

2:33 PM, October 30, 2005  
Blogger Complete Game said...

Who's Ron Paul? And where'd that one dude find the pci of the donkey with a boner?

11:34 AM, October 31, 2005  
Anonymous Anonymous said...

that donkey is hung like a yak

12:10 PM, October 31, 2005  
Blogger Dongley Shlongford said...

Just who are you calling a Donkey?

8:25 AM, November 01, 2005  
Blogger Dongley Shlongford said...

That's flaccid baby!

10:59 AM, November 01, 2005  
Anonymous baby care said...

http://www.babycare.net.in

baby care is not the meaning of only physical care of baby but also think about the Perception
and sensory development,Communication and languagedevelopment,Cognitive development,Emotional
Development ,Social Development.

12:06 AM, January 17, 2007  
Anonymous moviesmania said...

http://www.moviesmania.org

movies mania is website for a pop-culture website covering movies,
television, music, pro-wrestling, politics, sports, video games, and more........

12:08 AM, January 17, 2007  
Anonymous Computers said...

http://www.computers-guide.co.in

In the developed world, virtually every profession makes use of computers.
However, certain professional and academic disciplines have evolved that
specialize in techniques to construct, program, and use computers.
Terminology for different professional disciplines is still somewhat fluid and
new fields emerge from time to time

12:10 AM, January 17, 2007  
Anonymous RAIANS said...

RAIANS ,job placement services job placement
company job placement tests Cat ,cat stevens, arctic
cat cat list cat pictures cat names cat health care cat breeds funny cat videos cat
dog black cat B2b ,b2b marketing b2b website
b2b marketplace china b2b b2b sales b2b e-commerce yahoo b2b global b2b trade marketplace
Cruise ,carnival cruise suri cruise disney cruise
cruise lines cruise critic princess cruise royal caribbean cruise cruise ships
Flight ,flight tracker flight simulator flight
tracking american airlines flight flight status continental airlines flight flight centre
Poker ,free online poker full tilt poker party
poker poker stars poker tables poker games poker hands texas holdem poker poker rules
Flooring ,laminate flooring hardwood flooring
wood flooring bamboo flooring armstrong flooring vinyl flooring pergo flooring cork
flooring lindsay Lohan ,lindsay lohan pics
lindsay lohan photos lindsay lohan rumors lindsay lohan lyrics lindsay lohan 2005 free
lindsay lohan pics Lingeries ,hot lingeries linger
ies office womens lingeries lingeries pic wholesale lingeries best lingeries teddy lingeri
es Women ,wonder woman beautiful woman pictures pretty
woman picture woman dress barn woman man woman celtic woman phenomenal woman
Health ,health insurance mens health womens health
yahoo health health information discovery health department of health health articles
Helth care ,united health care home health care
information aetna com health care health care management salary minnesota health care program
Computer ,your complete guide to PC computers peripherals
and upgrades Dating Online ,Online Dating Free Online Dating
dating romance online romance chat online blinddates Child ,Designed
for parents and caregivers of children ages 3 to 6 Movies ,showtimes
90028 dvd showtimes 90028 los angelesshowtimes 90028 los angeles movie theater, showtimes 90028 philippines
Click ,sound click click 2 houston click on detroit click five
point and click games click the city pay per click Pregnancy
,pregnancy symptoms pregnancy calendar signs of pregnancy pregnancy calculator pregnancy test
stages of pregnancy ectopic pregnancy pregnancy due date pregnancy due date calculator

12:11 AM, January 17, 2007  
Anonymous RAIANS said...

RAIANS ,job placement services job placement
company job placement tests Swimsuit ,sports
illustrated swimsuit swimsuit models swimsuit coverups swimsuit pics swimsuit girls
ms no swimsuit swimsuit contest hot swimsuit anime girls Tutorials ,tutorial is a computer program designed to assist users in
learning a software Baby ,baby rabbit care baby
care tips baby duck care baby care center baby squirrel care baby bunny care baby goat
care baby care products baby turtle care
Photographs
,aerial photographs famous photographs black and whitephotographs
satellite photographs tornado alley photographs free photographs photographs,ghost
photographs Night vision , Mental health ,national mental health association national
mental health day department of mental health mental health jobs mental health disorders
mental health act Online casino ,free casino
games online casino morongo casino foxwoods casino pechanga casino mohegan sun casino
harrahs casino casino royale turning stone casino
Online Dating
,free online dating online dating services online sim dating games
online dating sites bookofmatches online dating christian online dating amateurmatch
online dating Aishwarya rai ,aishwarya rai
aishwarya rai pictures aishwarya rai dies aishwarya rai wallpapers aishwarya rai forever
aishwarya rai miss world 1994 Health insurance
,aetna health insurance health insurance quotes humana health insurance affordable
health insurance individual health insurance Voip ,
voip providers voip phone free voip voip service voip stunt voip pbx voip buster yahoo
voip voip reviews voip cheap voip phone services voip why voip solution att voip
voice over ip Wifi ,intendo wifi wifi hotspots
smart wifi free wifi psp wifi max Depression
,the great depression symptoms of depression postpartum depression Fitness ,24 hour fitness lifetime fitness bally fitness muscle and
fitness mens fitness physical fitness fitness magazine fitness models planet fitness
Furnitures ,ashley furniture value city
furniture wickes furniture furniture stores ikea furniture bedroom furniture office
furniture Movies ,movie dvd movie rental movie
theater free porn movie dans movie free sex movie
Outsourcing
,business process outsourcing outsourcing jobs india outsourcing hr
outsourcing accounting and finance outsourcing
Printing
,screen printing t-shirt printing printing press business card printing
Skin care ,skin care products natural skin care
dry skin care care skin anti aging skin care care product reviw skin Business cards ,business card templates business card design
free business card templates business card printing business card software business
card size Exporters ,japanese used car exporters
indian exporters largest oil exporters pakistan rice exporters china exporters brazil
sugar exporters astrology ,yahoo astrology
chinese astrology astrology zone free astrology msn astrology astrology signs astrology
compatibility indian astrology Will Smith ,
language translator sign language history of c language french translation dictionary
language japanese language All Stuffs ,insurance
insurance auto insurance montgage refinance stay extended extended stay home insurance
travel insurance Hot celebrities ,actor actress
movies top movies upcoming movies top actors top actresses current news on celebs upcoming movies 2005

12:12 AM, January 17, 2007  
Anonymous baby care said...

http://www.babycare.net.in

baby care is not the meaning of only physical care of baby but also think about the Perception
and sensory development,Communication and languagedevelopment,Cognitive development,Emotional
Development ,Social Development.

12:14 AM, January 17, 2007  
Anonymous Anonymous said...

Hello. Enjoyed your blog. I like the design and you have great content. Keep up the good work.

To see reviews of the Online Dating Sites please visit this site.

11:50 AM, February 24, 2007  
Blogger John Tiniakos said...

Hey nice blog.

For great articles on dating, relationship and romance tips please visit my site at Online Dating Sites blog

12:55 PM, February 25, 2007  
Anonymous Anonymous said...

i'm thinking of running dating site purely for the disabled



---------------
dating singles

9:23 PM, January 19, 2010  

Post a Comment

<< Home